Criticism and Response
There has been some criticism done on tablighi jamaat and those who do such criticism are of two types:
1. Those who challenge core tenants of jamaat and do not agree with it in entity
2. Those who see value in work done by tablighi jama'ah but believe that there are other ways in which dawah can be done more effectively
I have personally spent some time with Tablighi Jama'ah and can undoubtedly confirm that some of the accusations are completely baseless. Criticism that is absolutely biased and baseless is not included here to the best of my abilities. I am absolutely convinced about the sincerity and sacrifices of those who engage with this jama'ah.
However, an unbiased study may be helpful for readers. To facilitate that, I am presenting some views for and against tablighi jama'ah on this page.
May Allah keep us all on straight path and guide us if we go astray.
Ameen.
1. Those who challenge core tenants of jamaat and do not agree with it in entity
2. Those who see value in work done by tablighi jama'ah but believe that there are other ways in which dawah can be done more effectively
I have personally spent some time with Tablighi Jama'ah and can undoubtedly confirm that some of the accusations are completely baseless. Criticism that is absolutely biased and baseless is not included here to the best of my abilities. I am absolutely convinced about the sincerity and sacrifices of those who engage with this jama'ah.
However, an unbiased study may be helpful for readers. To facilitate that, I am presenting some views for and against tablighi jama'ah on this page.
May Allah keep us all on straight path and guide us if we go astray.
Ameen.
Criticsm
English - Advice for those who participate with tablighi jamaat (Read)
Urdu - Tableeghi Nisab ka Jaiza (Read / Download)
Urdu - Tableeghi Jamaat Ka Tehqeeqi Jaiza - Abdur Rahman Muhammadi (Read / Download)
Urdu - Tablighi Jmat Ki Ilmi Wa Amli Kamzoriyan (Read / Download)
Response:
English - Objection On Fazail – e – A’maal – A Basic Analysis By Shaykh Abdullah Maroofi (Read / Download)
English - Reality of Fazail e Amaal (Read / Download)
English - Tablighi Jamaat: Some misconceptions (Maulana Manzoor Nomani) - (Read / Download)
Roman English - Fazail e Amal per Aitrazat ka Ilmi Jaiza (Read / Download)
Urdu - Fazail e Amal per Aitrazat ka Ilmi Jaiza (Read / Download)
Urdu - Fazail e Amal per Aitrazat ka Usooli Jaiza (Read / Download)
Urdu - Fazail e Amaal per Aitrazat Kiyon (Read / Download)
Urdu - Jamat e Tableegh Per Aiterazaat Kay Jawabaat - Maulana Muhammad Zakariyyah (Read / Download)
Urdu - Kutub e Fazail per Ashkalat aur un ke jawabat (Read / Download)
Urdu - Sheikh Yusuf al Malahi Salafi Scholar book on Tablighi Jamaat (Read / Download)
Urdu - Sheikh Al-Jazairi (Madina) - Tablighi Jammat Ka Bay Laag Jaiza (Read / Download)
Urdu - Tablighi Jamaat ka Dawah Manhaj aur Deeni Ilmi Fikri Asaas - Maulana Syed Suleiman Nadvi and Maulana Syed Abul Hasan Nadvi (Read / Download)
Urdu - Tableeghi Jamaat Chand Haqaaiq wa Ghalat Fehmiyan (Read / Download)
Urdu - Tableeghi Jamaat Aur Kutub e Fazail – Haqaiq , Ghalat Fehmiyan (Read / Download)
Urdu - Tableeghi Jamaat – Ishaatut Tawheed was Sunnah Kay Nishana e Tanqeed Per (Read / Download)
Urdu - Tasheeh ul Qiyaal Tehqeeq ul Maqaal Fii Takhreej e Ahadees Fazail e Amaal (Read / Download)
English - Reality of Fazail e Amaal (Read / Download)
English - Tablighi Jamaat: Some misconceptions (Maulana Manzoor Nomani) - (Read / Download)
Roman English - Fazail e Amal per Aitrazat ka Ilmi Jaiza (Read / Download)
Urdu - Fazail e Amal per Aitrazat ka Ilmi Jaiza (Read / Download)
Urdu - Fazail e Amal per Aitrazat ka Usooli Jaiza (Read / Download)
Urdu - Fazail e Amaal per Aitrazat Kiyon (Read / Download)
Urdu - Jamat e Tableegh Per Aiterazaat Kay Jawabaat - Maulana Muhammad Zakariyyah (Read / Download)
Urdu - Kutub e Fazail per Ashkalat aur un ke jawabat (Read / Download)
Urdu - Sheikh Yusuf al Malahi Salafi Scholar book on Tablighi Jamaat (Read / Download)
Urdu - Sheikh Al-Jazairi (Madina) - Tablighi Jammat Ka Bay Laag Jaiza (Read / Download)
Urdu - Tablighi Jamaat ka Dawah Manhaj aur Deeni Ilmi Fikri Asaas - Maulana Syed Suleiman Nadvi and Maulana Syed Abul Hasan Nadvi (Read / Download)
Urdu - Tableeghi Jamaat Chand Haqaaiq wa Ghalat Fehmiyan (Read / Download)
Urdu - Tableeghi Jamaat Aur Kutub e Fazail – Haqaiq , Ghalat Fehmiyan (Read / Download)
Urdu - Tableeghi Jamaat – Ishaatut Tawheed was Sunnah Kay Nishana e Tanqeed Per (Read / Download)
Urdu - Tasheeh ul Qiyaal Tehqeeq ul Maqaal Fii Takhreej e Ahadees Fazail e Amaal (Read / Download)